Unlawful terms in your B2B relationship? An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.

Posted on

Posted in Interim management

The law of 4 April 2019 introduced three new sets of rules on companies in Belgium: A ban on unfair market practices which has been in force since 1 September 2019, from 1 June 2020 it will be prohibited to abuse the economic dependence on a weaker contracting party and finally from 1 December 2020 a ban on unlawful clauses between companies shall be applicable to new contracts, but also to existing contracts which are subsequently renewed or


At first glance, December 2020 seems far away, but given the fact that the rules will automatically apply to all existing contracts as soon as they are renewed or amended, it’s advisory to act today by making your new contracts futureproof.

The sanction for the presence of an unlawful clause is “only” the nullity of this clause. The rest of the contract remains valid in principle. If the sanction on having agreed an unlawful clause is only that your contracting party might one day dispute its enforceability before court, one might ask whether it is strictly necessary from a commercial point of view to remove all potentially unlawful clauses proactively?
Although this may be true for certain clauses, caution is nevertheless advisory: Since September of this year, the Commercial Court has been given competence to assess unlawful market practices between companies and in doing so, according to the new law, the court will specifically take into account “the contractual position of one company vis-à-vis the other company”.
For companies in a dominant position, even more caution is required, namely should the Belgian Competition Authority asses the clauses in the context of the prohibition of abusing the economic dependence of a weaker contracting party, which will already be possible as of 1 June 2020 and where the Competition Authority could consider that the clause could affect competition on (a substantial part of) the Belgian market concerned. According to the new law, the imposition of unfair contractual conditions is one of the possible indications of abuse of a position of economic dependence. Abuse of economic dependence can be sanctioned by the Competition Authority, ex officio or after a complaint, with fines up to 2% of a companies’ turnover.
It is therefore advisable to already screen your contracts today. Incidentally, this is not insurmountable, it is sufficient to check whether there are strictly forbidden so-called black clauses and remove them, and to screen if there are so-called gray clauses and, depending on the situation, remove them, adjust them or even leave them in, provided there is reasonable justification to do so.

Curious as to whether all your contractual conditions pass the test or do you have any further questions? Please contact us via info@panderim.jobs. We are happy to put you in contact with our candidates.